PAYE & ICR Plans Reopening for Student Loan Borrowers

By Mark Ziety, CFP®, AIF®, Financial Advisor, WisMed Financial

The Pay As You Earn (PAYE) and Income Contingent Repayment (ICR) plans will reopen in mid-December under an Interim Final Rule. For borrowers forced into forbearance under the Saving on a Valuable Education (SAVE) repayment plan, should you switch plans? Let’s find out.

Focusing on SAVE vs. PAYE only

ICR is typically only used by parent borrowers with Parent Plus loans or consolidated Parent Plus loans. Income Based Repayment (IBR) is also available for borrowers, but the payment amount and treatment of interest are equal to or substandard to PAYE and SAVE plans. Therefore, this article will focus on SAVE vs. PAYE.

Problems with SAVE

As of this writing, borrowers in the SAVE plan have been placed in forbearance with no interest, no payment, and no progress toward loan forgiveness. It’s anticipated this forbearance will last well into 2025.

Making progress toward loan forgiveness

There are two options currently.

• Switch from SAVE to a different payment plan, like PAYE, with required payments and progress toward loan forgiveness.

• Anticipate using the PSLF Buyback program later to complete the 120 payments needed for forgiveness (assuming this program can be used to buyback months for the current forbearance.)

Comparing SAVE vs PAYE

• Payment: Monthly payment under SAVE is typically lower than PAYE. The exception is at high income levels. The PAYE payment rises with higher income, but it is capped at the 10-year standard payment. The SAVE payment rises with higher income uncapped.

• Interest: For those with relatively low income compared to their debt, the SAVE plan is often better than PAYE. The SAVE plan prevents interest from accruing when the monthly payment does not cover the interest. In contrast, unpaid interest accrues under the PAYE plan until it accumulates to 10% of the loan amount.

• Length of Repayment: Loan forgiveness for borrowers that don’t qualify for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) takes 20 years under PAYE. Under SAVE, forgiveness takes 20 years for undergrad loans, 25 years for graduate loans, or 10 years if the original amount borrowed was $12,000 or less.

Should you switch?

Everyone needs to run their own calculation to see what makes sense for their situation. Many borrowers will benefit by sticking with the SAVE plan if they are working for a government or 501(c)3 non-profit organization, assuming the PSLF Buyback program can be used to gain credit for the current forbearance later. For those with high income and/or their employer doesn’t qualify them for PSLF, switching to PAYE might be worthwhile.

For personalized help eliminating debt, investing smart and securing retirement, please contact Mark Ziety, CFP®, AIF® 608.442.3750.

Mark Ziety, CFP®, AIF®

WisMed Financial, Inc. part of the Wisconsin Medical Society